Answering the Modern Indictments of the
Bible: Why Does It Allow Slavery and
Subjugation of Women?
These days, a lot of people are
turned off by organized religion, and one of the most common issues they bring
up is the Biblical support for slavery and the non-equality of women. But, as I will show you in this post, only by
forgetting the real conditions that existed in the world in Biblical times can
they make these comments. Given the conditions that existed when God first made His presence known to Moses in Old Testament times, a new law abolishing slavery or making women equal to men would have been harmful or even dangerous to slaves, women and children.
Let’s look closely at why this was true at that time.
As you may or may not know, people more than 4000 years ago
experienced very different lives than we have.
They lived in tribes, which were nomadic groups moving from place to
place, looking for enough food and shelter for all their members, which was a
daily challenge for them. Back then, humans
then had not figured out all the things we know now about having successful
societies, so they constantly worried about their very survival from day to day.
If your tribe was on good land that
could supply enough food to feed all your tribe’s people, you could be certain
that other tribes would be nearby wanting to take that land from you so they
could feed their families. As a
result, the men in these tribes were primarily warriors, since they had to
defend the tribe from other tribes.
The picture described above goes
a long way in understanding everything about the rules in these societies. The system of laws before God appeared to
Moses to establish new laws was best illustrated by “Hammurabi’s Code,” the
first written system of laws that was established in Babylon eighteen thousand
years before Jesus came. It can be
summarized as follows: if you committed
a crime against another person, you would be put to death. The idea there was that if you
make punishment so scary and carry it out so predictably, people would
generally behave themselves and follow the law.
In fact, this was necessary, because it was impossible to have other systems of punishment, such as jails, back then. Not only did the tribes move
around from place to place, but they could not spare any men to guard the
wrongdoers, since all the men were needed to protect and feed the tribe.
And here is where slavery came into the picture. (First, though, it is important to note that
unlike when we modern Americans picture “slavery,” it was not a racial
thing. Slaves in Biblical times could be
of any color, background or geographical origin.) Imagine a fight was underway between two tribes over good, fertile land sufficient to feed one tribe and ensure that that tribe would to grow and flourish.
At the end of this, one side would win and the other would lose. What to do with the losers? Not only were there no jails, you could not
just chase away the losers, because if you did this, the winners would not be
safe for long, since the losers would come back to try again very
shortly. In this situation, the only realistic
choices were to either kill the losers or make them slaves. So you
see, back in Biblical times, slavery was performing a very useful function – it
was allowing large groups of people to stay alive instead of being killed on
the spot at the end of a war. It also performed other valuable functions by
allowing a person to work off his or her debts to another person, or ensuring
that a poor person had food and shelter, as a master had a societal duty to feed, clothe
and house his slaves.
Similarly, in terms of the status of women, those who think
it would have been better for God’s law to have made women and men equal are
making a key mistake in forgetting the circumstances that existed back in
Biblical times. It is true that women were treated as essentially “property” of
the men, being handed from father to husband at marriage. But this was not an evil system forced on the
women by men who wanted to oppress the women – on the contrary, it was a mutually
advantageous arrangement that was a logical response to the circumstances of
those times.
Remember how dangerous life was back then? It was a constant worry whether the tribe
would have enough food or get attacked by another tribe. And don’t forget that in Biblical times, once
a woman got married, she spent her life more often pregnant than not (not only
did they not have birth control, but tribes wanted to grow and become stronger
through having many children). The
fragile condition of pregnancy just made it that much more important for a
woman to have someone capable whose duty
it was to protect and feed her and the young children. Realistically speaking, only a man could do
this job, and therefore, this duty of men was woven into the structure of the
tribal society. Until a girl got married, her father had the duty to protect
and feed her, and then this obligation passed to the husband. Having this kind of protector meant the
difference between life and death for a woman and her children at the time, so
the women welcomed these rules.
So we see that in the conditions that existed back in Old Testament times, a law decreeing slavery illegal, or a law making women equal to men, would have created mass chaos and confusion, and resulted in the needless death of many, including primarily women and children. Besides
which, there’s a final reason that is the best of all for why God did not do
this when He gave Moses the laws that the Jews had to live by: if He
had, the Jews would have laughed instead of obeying – changes like that would
have appeared simply crazy to them at the time!
Next post: Why the
Laws of the Old Testament Were Actually a Huge Step Towards the Development of
Modern Human Rights
No comments:
Post a Comment